For twenty years now, the Pantone Institute has been identifying the color that will set trends for the coming year. In 2020, the dominant shade was supposed to be Classic Blue, which "encourages thinking outside the box." And although the past year was far from colorful in many respects, it is still worth applying a marketing color palette to that period and summarizing 2020 from this perspective.
The dominant colors of last year certainly included: Eco Green with numerous pro-environmental initiatives; Proud Rainbow, through which many important issues concerning LGBT+ communities were addressed; and Feminine Pink with a range of activations tackling gender discrimination. Campaigns of this type, though extremely important, did not attract much of my interest, because for years they have occupied a place in the foreground of the marketing landscape. The year 2020 therefore caught my attention with completely different shades. I am talking about Moldy Green, Rotting White, and Month-Past-Expiry-Date Bronze – the colors of decay adorning the Whopper from Burger King. The colors of anti-advertising realism, which sporadically but extremely boldly adorned the picturesque marketing landscape last year.
What exactly is anti-advertising?
How should the term "anti-advertising" be understood in the first place? There have been many attempts to describe and systematize this term. Most often, reversed psychology, honesty, and breaking the fourth wall are mentioned as hallmarks of anti-advertising. In addition, attention is paid to self-referentiality, humor, and the absence of overt product placement or even the brand's logo itself. It is also emphasized that anti-advertising constitutes a complete "opposite and negation of standard advertising." One of the precursors of the described form of marketing is usually said to be Volkswagen and its 1959 campaign with the slogans "Think small" or "Lemon," promoting the Beetle. D dictionary-style containment of anti-advertising, given so many different markers, becomes a difficult and complicated task. I do not want to impose here some exceptionally narrow framework in which I would try to capture the term under analysis, which after all evolves and expands its meaning with every new creation. In my view, anti-advertising can be described in the broadly understood categories of negation of standard advertising, in which the promoted product (or service) is always spoken of favorably and its attributes are emphasized along with the exposure of the brand logo. Anti-advertising is none of that. But what was it like in 2020, and why does it have a chance to become a permanent fixture in the creations of the coming years?
Burger King and the beauty of mold
In February, Burger King prepared a controversial action, "The Moldy Whopper," presenting its flagship product in a rather unusual form. As part of the activation, a 34-day timelapse of a moldy sandwich was shown, which visually had nothing to do with appetizing appeal. Nevertheless, the burger's "imperfections" were only seemingly its flaws. The final message ("The beauty of no artificial preservatives") perfectly capped the whole story, attempting to turn the initially negative tone ultimately to its own advantage. The phenomenon of anti-advertising was expressed here by showing a completely unappetizing product that, instead of deliciously stimulating the senses, repelled and pushed away. And yet the campaign drew users' attention and sparked broad discussion on social media.
The brand's action can therefore be considered in terms of anti-advertising, which, unlike standard marketing practices, does not present an idealized world or product. On the contrary – it exposes defects, but only in order to make a communication volte-face and turn flaws into advantages. And although anti-advertising is not an innovative means of expression, I have the impression that in the near future we may witness the continuation of this trend. Especially since the response and sentiment of Burger King fans were overwhelmingly positive.
The trend was also used by the Polish branch of Burger King, which in November published a message on its fanpage encouraging people to order food from other restaurants as well. In this way, the brand tried to support the entire industry in the face of pandemic restrictions. And although the brands mentioned in the message could indeed benefit from such an action, the greatest benefits ultimately go to Burger King, which builds its image on empathy.
However, among anti-advertising efforts, fully intentional ones are less common. More often, completely accidental and spontaneous ones dominate – not resulting from a conscious process. Such a situation is always a considerable challenge for a brand, whose reaction will affect its image and perception.
Anti-advertising, Polish style: Apart and the Golec brothers
One of the "victims" of spontaneous anti-advertising was the already famous Apart commercial, whose overly sweet and artificially created world was parodied by Klub Komediowy. The brand's reaction was to publish a short message in a comment under the video: "You made our day with this. :D We already know who will be making our next commercial! (...)" In this way, Apart performed the so-called "embrace the meme," fully accepting the role assigned to it. This move is the simplest, but it seems still effective, method of making a communication turn and turning criticism into positive connotations with the brand. To show contrast, it is worth mentioning the completely opposite reaction of the Golec brothers. In 2017, the musicians reprimanded internet users who had remixed one of the band's songs. The artists called on them to remove the copyright-infringing work, which of course met with an even greater wave of meme remixes defaming the Golc brothers. Apart's response was therefore the right reaction, thanks to which the brand effectively avoided a potential Streisand effect, while eliminating the negative anti-advertising tone.